
Personal Writings
"Failed Illusions"

Back to WRITINGS
October 23, 2006
THE 1956 HUNGARIAN REVOLT – PERSONAL NOTES 50 YEARS LATER
I just finished reading a book about the 56 Revolution by my lifelong friend, Charles Gati (Failed Illusions). Before going any further I wish to state that I think he did a super job in all aspects, i.e., collecting, analyzing, presenting and backing up the information. Notwithstanding, I would lie if I said that I enjoyed reading the book. I did not. I did not for a number of reasons.
First, the period up to November 1956 described the “age of our youth”. That is the period when the four of us (Szaby, George, Charles and I) became close friends, when we had a good time, and when we had some very difficult times. Our friendships (and playing ulti) did help to “block out” some of the horrendous things that happened around us, but not all. The book brought back all the events which, most likely, I have been blocking out for convenience for a long time now, and because I prefer thinking about the future rather than about the past, particularly about the bad aspects of the past.
I was aware of most of the events of those days, but the interrelationships amongst the Russian leaders, amongst the Hungarian leaders, and between the Russian and Hungarian leaders, and who was for whom were new to me. Somehow I remembered that Mikoyan was considered to be the good guy (the “Great Russian Hope” to help us) but that’s all.
What is most interesting that we (Charles, George and I) never discussed that period, specifically what happened to each of us in 1956, except, of course, how the events impacted our lives. Of course, George and I left together and the associated experience was mutual. Twenty years later, when I started to go back, Szaby and I spent lots of time on this. But before getting into that, let me touch on what happened to me between October 22 and November 4.
On October 22nd I was at the Technical University, where I was a fifth year student. We already knew what the architects did in Szeged, and a friend of mine George Fek told me that a group is getting together on the Danube embankment, in front of the central entrance to the main building. They screamed “Flowers to Bem” and “Long live Poznan” (Bem was a Polish general who helped the Hungarians in the great revolution of 1848-49). A large number of students started to march along the Danube towards S zaby’s old apartment, which was next to Bem’s statue. I had to meet Vera (my girlfriend) somewhere, so I did not go with the crowd then, but returned from the north (from the Margit Bridge). By the time I got to Bem Square, some of the students already put flowers under the Bem statue, and the brief proceedings that included some speeches were over. There was still quite a crowd there.
On Tuesday night (October 23) Szaby and I were playing cards (ulti) at Gyuri’s, in Mester utca, and his father came in that there are “tuntetesek” (street protest), it is best if you go home. It was – I think – just after eight. Szaby and I took a bus at the corner of Mester utca and the Nagykorut (Big Boulevard). We were the only ones on the bus. Before getting to Ulloi ut, the bus came to a screeching halt. Somebody stepped in front of it. A drunk man with an armband with an arrow cross on it and with a gun in his hand started to scream: “are there any jews on this bus?” I said to him: “Testver (brother), only the two of us, my buddy here and I are here, nobody else”. He said “Good” and he got off. Szaby got off at Rakoczi ut, I got off at th e Vigszinhaz. I saw masses marching down toward the parliament. I went with them. I was at the northern end of Kossuth Square, could not hear much, I remember Nagy making some statement, but what I remember most was the crowd screaming: “Vegyek le a csillagot” (“Remove the red star!”) I got home well after Midnight. My mother was scared about where I was.
I spent one day (I don’t remember which) at the university, and volunteered to guard a weapon depot, a room created for that purpose, where all kinds of weapons and ammunitions were stored. I spent six hours there, and then somebody else came. I went home, and did not leave for many days.
My mother told me that if the Russians will interfere, they will do it early Sunday morning, most major battles started that way. Generally speaking because of her job, she was extremely well informed. She was in charge of the reference library at “Nepszava” (one of the three largest daily papers), and had access to western papers. Indeed on November 4th at 6 a.m. the tanks and cannons started up. Just before my (23rd) birthday , on the 13th, a few days after Charles left, I said f… all this, I am history, called George and Szaby and told them I am going. George agreed and joined me, somewhat reluctantly, but Szaby did not want to leave his girlfriend (likely the worst decision he had ever made – for more reasons than one). I still think about the serious battles I had to fight to come out and, even more, to have George come out. My family (except my mother) wanted me to stay with my mother who was alone (my father died in WW II and I was an only child, so were all my three friends!). My aunt Klari wanted George to stay, and stated that if anything happens to him she will hold me responsible.
The rest was history. I did not go back for 20 years. By then my mother died, but I found my relatives who stayed behind relatively well. I also found Szaby well (my friend who stayed behind), and we reestablished our friendship. He was the only person (with his future wife) who came to my wedding with Ann to St. Moritz and he was my best man. Later we spent three vacations together, and he became the Manager of the Budapest office of my company.
He made an interesting observation: If you (I) stayed here, you probably would not be alive by now. Not because you would have joined some crazy, hopeless opposition fraction, but because you would have said and/or done something as an individual that those in power would not have been able to tolerate. He probably was right.
In late 1975, just after I returned from my first, very brief trip back to Hungary, I was asked by a writer who was working on the history of first generation immigrants in the XXth century**, if I would be willing to tell my story, which would be verbatim presented as an oral history. I agreed, and I invited her to our house where the interview was to happen. It was in January 1976. We had several drinks and I was waiting to see when we formally start, and asked her about it. At that point she told me that she has been taping me all evening. I did not quite appreciate it (and told her so), but went along. The result was somewhat different than it would have been if I had a chance to plan it and organize the story (and watch my words). At any rate, at the end I include t he portion on our escape unaltered, because from my point of view our escape (George and I left together) was an integral part of the events of 1956. The description was given with a perspective of less than 20 years, in comparison to the current memory after 50 years.
Going back to Charles’ book, I became quite depressed reading the sections on what was going on, that I could do nothing, and, most importantly, how much depended on the single decision (to leave) I made as a 23 year old, in love with a beautiful and intelligent woman whom I had to leave there, and doing it only four months before getting my University degree, which, at that point I thought I probably will never get. Yet, it was the best decision I ever made.
Adding to my depression was the realization that very little changed in the world during these fifty years. As my friend Charles writes, 1956 played out in three places, in Budapest, in Moscow and in Washington.
Russia is what I know the least about, but I am not convinced that all have changed. Imprisonments not too long ago and recent executions show that not only enemies but critics of the regime are not safe even now.
In Hungary the leaders, while now they don’t kill each other (perhaps they would like to), they are fighting amongst themselves with beyond normal hostility, they are lying, stealing, etc., and consider political opponents enemies. The insurgents then were mostly from the 8th and 9th district, young and uneducated (as described on pages 155-157 of the English edition). The same people, most likely their grandchildren who probably live in the same apartments as their grandparents did, are the ones who camp out in front of the Parliament now. Their ideological description would be probably the same as well. Most importantly, few if anybody, worries about what the best is for the country, rather they worry about themselves and their party,
In the US the similarity is the strongest. Like then, the current government doesn’t want to hit singles either because home runs are possible even if not probable. Now, like then, they knew what they wanted, but never thought through how to get there, and thought every problem will be somehow miraculously resolved (footnote 93). Now, like then, the CIA did not have the foggiest idea about what is going on in the target country (pg 95). In fact, then at Radio Free Europe, they got their information through émigrés who had their own political agenda, and did not know the local situation after being away for many years. Quite similar to 2003 here (Chalaby?).
The 1956 Hungarian revolt failed. Some believe it did not have to fail. I believe that what was necessary in order not to fail was something that in reality could not have happened in the short time available. Leaders in Washington and Moscow, and the insurgents (without a clear leader) in Budapest all would have had to want a compromise to work. I am no expert but I feel that none of them wanted a compromise, certainly not the obvious one (per Charles): a Titoist style country which would have become independent of Russia but would have remained communist for the time being.
Yet, the 1956 Hungarian revolt had a major impact. It showed to the world that the people of Eastern Europe did not support the system. Its immediate impact was the collapse of the communist parties of Western Europe. Some feel that the fact that neither in Spain nor in Portugal there was an attempt by the communists to take over after the death of Franco and Salazar was also a result of 1956. Arguably it was the beginning of the fall of the Soviet empire.
Finally, although I and my friends benefited immediately, as a result of prompt decision making and acting without hesitation when the situation became hopeless, it is our children who should be thankful, without any doubt they are the true beneficiaries of what happened.
* Charles Gati: Failed Illusions, Woodrow Wilson Center Press, Washington D.C., 2006
PREVIOUS:
NEXT:

